Exploring the Differences: Tethered vs. Untethered Charger Options

Home Exploring the Differences: Tethered vs. Untethered Charger Options
12/01/2024
Share:

As society progresses towards electric vehicular transport, the intricacies inherent to EV charging technologies assume a pivotal role. Tethered chargers, equipped with pre-attached cables, proffer the simplicity and immediacy of use, whereas untethered charging solutions, necessitating the procurement of an independent cable, deliver unparalleled flexibility and adaptability. Each variation possesses distinct advantages and potential limitations tailored to concord with the diverse proclivities and requirements of consumers. Discerning the salient features and distinctions between these charging modalities is instrumental in enhancing your electric vehicle user experience, ensuring seamless preparedness for your vehicular journeys.

Throughout this discourse, we shall navigate the complexities enveloping both tethered and untethered EV chargers. Whether you are embarking on the maiden voyage of EV ownership or contemplating an augmentation of your existing infrastructure, this exposition aims to furnish you with profound understanding and assist you in selecting an option that impeccably aligns with your lifestyle and charging requisites.

tethered or untethered charger

What is a Tethered EV Charger?

A tethered EV charger is an electromechanical unit equipped with an integral cable, providing a consummate plug-and-play solution for electric vehicle operators. This apparatus may be affixed to a structural wall or mounted upon a stanchion in proximity to one’s vehicular parking area and is seamlessly interfaced with the domestic electrical infrastructure. The convenience of a pre-attached charging conduit obviates the necessity to undertake a search for a disparate charging apparatus – the unit stands as a stalwart adjunct to both quotidian commutes and extended voyages. One merely inserts the tethered cable into the electric vehicle, whereupon the electricity transfusion commences. Several tethered apparatuses further boast sophisticated user interfaces, encompassing luminous diode indicators or interactive displays, to impart instantaneous metrics on the charge progression, electric energy expenditure, and additional relevant indices.

The cord of a tethered charger is designed in a spectrum of lengths, generally extending from 5 to 8 meters, to accommodate an assortment of vehicular parking layouts and the respective distances from the charging node to the automobile. In the realm of power transmission, these units exhibit adaptability, proffering options for both single-phase and polyphase (three-phase) currents. Single-phase devices are prevalent in residential environments, customarily delivering up to 7kW of power, which is quintessentially suitable for nocturnal recharging sessions. Conversely, polyphase apparatuses, capable of providing upwards of 22kW, are predominantly advantageous in commercial contexts where expedited charging is frequently a precondition. Predominantly, these charging stations are manufactured with either a Type 1 or Type 2 coupling, the selection of which is governed by regional standards and vehicular congruity. The Type 2 connection prevails across the European sector, whilst the Type 1 interface is ubiquitous in the United States, predominantly associated with single-phase charging systems.

tethered or untethered charger

Pros of Tethered Chargers

  • Convenience: Always attached, ready for use.
  • Theft Protection: Less risk of cable theft.
  • Durability: Often more robust due to less frequent handling.

Cons of Tethered Chargers

  • Flexibility: Limited by cable length.
  • Compatibility: May not fit all types of electric cars.
  • Portability: Not easily transportable for charging at various locations.

Tethered Charger Compatibility

While offering expediency, tethered electric vehicle chargers sometimes confront challenges with compatibility. These units, distinguished by their indelibly affixed cabling, cannot claim universality in their application due to the diversity of connector standards in the electric mobility landscape. Amongst electric conveyances, there exists a multitude of connector designs catering to variegated models and manufacturers. Predominantly observed within the United States are the J1772 connectors, tailored for single-phase electrical provision, a typical feature of privately utilized electric vehicles, and the CCS (Combined Charging System) connectors, which accommodate the more rapid polyphase charging requisite for the newer echelons of electric vehicle innovation. In contrast, Tesla Motors employs an exclusive connector design – the Tesla Wall Connector for its fleet, albeit adaptors are procurable to render compatibility with the standard connectors.

The tethered charger’s embedded cable length is also crucial in determining connector compatibility. The conventional charging cable measures span approximately 16 feet (or near 5 meters) to 25 feet (approximately 8 meters), a length generally adequate for domestic usage to bridge the span between the charging station and the automobile. Nevertheless, within commercial settings or domiciles presenting unconventional vehicular placement, it is paramount that the cable length is meticulously evaluated to meet explicit situational demands. Electric vehicle proprietors must engage in careful deliberation regarding the appropriate charging station and cable length that is most conducive to fulfilling their specific vehicle demands.

What is an Untethered EV Charger?

An untethered electric vehicle charger presents itself as a paragon of versatility within the domain of electric vehicle power supply infrastructure, analogous to a chameleon with its capacity for adaptation. Installable on either a wall or a pedestal, these chargers imbibe the principle of portability, allowing for fluid relocation should the exigencies of charging requisites evolve. In stark contrast to its tethered analogue, an untethered charger eschews the concept of a fixed cable, thereby endorsing its status as a multi-faceted power interface for a diverse array of electric vehicles and charging situations.

This charging port boasts universal compatibility, effacing the constraints that typically beset electrical connection types. Regardless of whether your vehicle is furnished with a Type 1 or Type 2 inlet, the employment of this charger remains unimpeded; one merely necessitates the insertion of an appropriate cable into the home EV charger or public chargers to initiate the power transfer process. This attribute is particularly advantageous for residential complexes or commercial enterprises that maintain a cadre of electric vehicles of disparate makes and models, as it guarantees interoperability across an eclectic vehicle fleet.

With an untethered charger, the cable length ceases to be a limiting factor. Proprietors relish the autonomy to procure a cable that resonates with their precise circumstantial needs; whether it is a succinct length to mitigate disarray within a confined parking space or an elongated one imperative for bridging longer distances to the charging station. Such flexibility also permeates cable stewardship, permitting users to sequester the charging apparatus in a manner that ensures it remains unblemished and safeguarded against the elements or untoward wear when idle.

tethered or untethered charger

Benefits of Untethered Chargers

  • Versatility: Use with various cable types and lengths.
  • Upgradability: Easily switch to a new cable if standards change.
  • Portability: Ideal for those who charge in multiple locations.

Drawbacks of Untethered Chargers

  • Convenience: Requires connecting your own charging cable each time.
  • Cable Management: Need to store and maintain your own cable.
  • Initial Setup: May require purchasing a separate cable.

Flexibility of Untethered Chargers

Untethered chargers proffer greater flexibility, facilitating a customized charging infrastructure. Whether the necessity arises to procure a longer cable to connect to a charging point situated beyond the customary range, or there is a requirement to interchange cables for compatibility with a newly acquired electric vehicle, these chargers readily adapt to the dynamic landscape of electric vehicle ownership. The emphasis lies in tailoring the charging experience to align with individual lifestyles, rather than obliging users to adapt to the constraints of their charging equipment.

For those individuals who encounter scenarios mandating the relocation of their charger—be it transitioning to a new residence or reconfiguring the charger’s position within an existing environment—the portability of untethered units is exceptionally advantageous. This attribute renders them supremely suitable for ephemeral installations or communal charging infrastructures, where the need for easy, nonpermanent placement is paramount.

Key Considerations for Choosing

Personal Preferences and Usage Patterns

When choosing between a tethered or untethered charger for home charging, reflect on your daily EV use. Do you prioritize convenience or flexibility? Does your EV lifestyle demand a home charger that can adapt to different vehicles and situations?

Cost Comparison: Tethered or Untethered Charger?

In general, untethered chargers are recognized for their lower cost at the point of purchase when contrasted with their tethered counterparts. For example, an average untethered model may be procured at an approximate expenditure of $500, whereas a tethered variant may command a price of $600 or above, subject to the manufacturer’s prestige and the array of functionalities provided. The price difference frequently originates from the absence of a permanently attached cable. Should one opt for an untethered charger, the acquisition of an extra detachable cable is necessitated. The monetary outlay for a standard electrical vehicle charging conductor may fluctuate between $150 and $300, a variance ascribed to the conductor’s length and configuration. Consequently, the aggregate expenditure on an untethered charger in conjunction with an untethered cable might eclipse the ostensibly modest initial quotation, thereby potentially mirroring or surpassing the investment required for a tethered apparatus.

Subsequent to installation, the fiscal obligations associated with the upkeep and enhancement of these charging systems may diverge. Tethered units, equipped with inextricable cables, are prone to elevated preservation or exchange expenses in the event of cable impairment. By contrast, an untethered charger presents an uncomplicated and typically more economical solution for conducting line substitution. Nevertheless, should technological norms evolve or the acquisition of a new electric vehicle transpire, the necessity to modernize the entire tethered system could arise, entailing expenditures that may significantly outweigh those associated with the mere interchange of a conducting line in an untethered setup.

Security and Theft Prevention

Tethered chargers often come with built-in theft protection, such as cable lock features, which secures the cable to the charger when not in use. It can be a significant advantage, especially in public or semi-public charge points like apartment complexes or workplace parking lots, where the risk of theft or tampering is higher.

While untethered chargers offer the advantage of flexibility, they do require more diligence in terms of security. Since the charging cable is detachable, it becomes a separate component that can be targeted by thieves. Owners of untethered chargers need to be mindful of storing their cables securely when not in use.

Some EV drivers opt for additional security measures, such as investing in lockable cable bags or secure cable storage boxes. There’s also a growing trend of integrating cable lock systems within the EV itself, allowing the cable to be locked to the car during charging. This dual-security approach – locking both the cable to the car and the car to the charger – significantly reduces the risk of theft.

Future-Proofing Your Charging Solution

Untethered chargers stand out for their superior adaptability, offering electric vehicle proprietors the flexibility to update or exchange cables in response to the advent of novel vehicle models or shifts in industry protocols, all without necessitating the obsolescence of the entire charging mechanism. Envision, for instance, the introduction of a more expeditious charging paradigm or an alternate style of connection interface; users of untethered systems are equipped to conveniently acquire a new cable aligned with these modern specifications. This malleability not only epitomizes a fiscally prudent strategy but concurrently embodies an eco-sensitive ethos by maintaining the principal unit, thereby curtailing wasteful practices.

An illustrative example of such versatility is observable within the European market’s progression from Type 1 to Type 2 connectors. Elective Vehicle enthusiasts with untethered systems were able to transition effortlessly to the prevailing standard by merely interchanging the cable, obviating the necessitation for an extensive and costly charger overhaul.

Meanwhile, tethered charging units, despite their limited faculties for cable modification, are not devoid of provisions to safeguard their longevity. A multitude of contemporary tethered models are imbued with advanced functionalities — among them, modifiable power outputs, firmware enhancements, and intelligent charging faculties. These innovations ensure ongoing harmony with new electric vehicle designs, besides affording adaptability to fluctuations in energy pricing and bespoke charging practices.

Which is Better?

FeatureTethered ChargerUntethered Charger
Initial CostTypically higher, includes cableLower, but requires extra cost for cable
Cable TypePermanently attached, limited flexibilityChoose any compatible cable, adaptable
Cable LengthFixed, ranging 4-8 metersCustomizable based on user’s choice
InstallationRequires professional setup, potentially more complexGenerally simpler, more versatile in placement
Power OutputOptions for single-phase (up to 7kW) and three-phase (up to 22kW)Depends on chosen cable, adaptable to different power outputs
CompatibilitySpecific to connector type (e.g., Type 1 or Type 2)Universal, depends on the cable used
MaintenanceCable damage can be costly to repairEasier and cheaper cable replacements
SecurityOften includes theft protection like cable locksRequires additional security measures for cable
PortabilityFixed in place, not easily transportableHighly portable, ideal for multiple locations
Future-ProofingMay need complete unit replacement for new standardsEasy cable replacement for new standards
Smart FeaturesVaries by model, can include monitoring and control optionsOften includes Wi-Fi/Bluetooth, remote control via apps
Environmental ImpactPotentially higher if unit needs replacementLower, as only the cable might need updating
User-FriendlinessReady to use, no separate cable managementRequires connecting cable each time
Overall SuitabilityIdeal for single-car households, consistent parkingPerfect for multiple EVs, changing cars, or flexible needs

The determination of superiority between tethered and untethered chargers is a matter not of absolutes but of context-dependent nuances. The optimal choice is contingent upon an individual’s precise necessities, the specific electric vehicle in their possession, and their customary charging practices. Each variant presents its own set of merits and constraints. For those valuing immediacy and desiring a charger that is consistently ready for deployment, tethered chargers emerge as the preeminent option for residential use. They cater to users favoring a plug-in-and-leave paradigm, particularly when a uniform parking configuration is established and the invariable cable length does not pose an inconvenience.

Conversely, untethered chargers are synonymous with versatility and adaptability, catering to users whose needs encapsulate potential shifts in electric vehicle models or prospective alterations in charging environs. They stand as the quintessential solution for proprietors of multiple electric vehicles and for those who appreciate the liberty to tailor their charging infrastructure.

In essence, the “better” charger is one that embodies a more harmonious integration with the user’s lifestyle preferences and electric vehicle utilization tendencies.

Select Beny for Your EV Charging Requirements

In your quest for an optimal EV charging solution, consider Beny EV Chargers as a formidable contender. Beny offers a wide assortment of charging systems, including AC chargers with integrated cables and socketed variations (both single and dual-port). Catering to a wide spectrum of preferences, Beny’s portfolio encompasses both wall-mounted or floor-standing models, ensuring a fit for diverse user requirements within the United States and beyond. Additionally, Beny provides portable EV chargers and DC fast-charging stations, supporting both residential and commercial applications. Connect with Beny today to secure a charger that supports your EV charging infrastructure needs.

Conclusion

Undertaking the transition to electric vehicle ownership necessitates astute deliberations concerning charging equipment options. Opting for either a tethered or untethered charging device signifies a commitment to an environmentally-conscious, sustainable trajectory. It is imperative to select a solution that resonates with your personal and electric car needs. Affirm this choice as an extension of your ecological ethos, and allow the forthcoming journey to be one marked by both innovation and electrification.

Talk to Our Expert